Yesterday was mystery, and today we’re moving to my favorite fantasy reads of the year… It was an interesting year for my fantasy TBR. I started the year expecting to read a hefty list of new releases… And while I read some on that list, I found a lot of joy in books published earlier, discovered almost accidentally. A good reminder for me that there’s so much out there to read beyond the latest releases…
My favorites this year spanned a wide range of fantasy. There was my (usual) preference for hard / political fantasy. Then there was a mystery series from one of my favorite fantasy authors (!). I also found a bookish fantasy that I really enjoyed reading… and a character deep-dive that felt timely and engaging. Let’s start with…
The Sword Catcher
I’ll confess that, despite years of fantasy readership, I’ve never read Cassandra Clare. But I found a copy of Sword Catcher in a Boston bookstore this year, and decided I should give it a shot. Between the court setting, the promise of hidden magic, and the idea of both a Sword Catcher and a Ragpicker King of the Underworld, I was excited for fantasy shenanigans and political intrigue…
And Sword Catcher did not disappoint. The book follows two protagonists – the titular Sword Catcher, Kel, and a young physician, Lin. They’re brought together when Kel needs some quick healing, but quickly realize that there’s something deeply wrong in the city of Castellane. The world itself is richly detailed (and quite rooted in ours, for better or worse), and the plot itself follows its and court intrigue in detail. The story felt a little bit like a traditional court intrigue story, set in a Tamora Pierce world (with a few modern twists).
This is much closer to hard fantasy than a more traditional epic or even romantasy – which may be surprising if you’re familiar with Clare. Fortunately for me, that’s my favorite kind of “pure” fantasy, and I’m eagerly awaiting the next installment.
A Winter’s Promise
My fantasy reading took on a bit of an international bent this year, ranging from stories set in AU Greece to modern Korea. I didn’t realize, when I picked up A Winter’s Promise, that it was translated from French – but it appears my fantasy readings tastes have shifted abroad. (Side note – I found this in the same Christopher’s Books trip that I found The Murder of Mr. Ma. Another point for in-person browsing!)
A Winter’s Promise takes place in world where the planet has split into several Arks, each with a distinct culture and personality. Ophelia, our protagonist, lives on Anima, where objects have souls that she can (secretly) read. When she’s engaged by her family to a member of another Ark, she must follow him to his icy home and try to navigate the court and political intrigues. The story is full of beautiful settings and interesting interpersonal puzzles, and I enjoyed learning more about the world of the Arks. And Ophelia, the protagonist, felt unfamiliar enough to me (perhaps because I’m used to American YA protagonist tropes) that I constantly felt surprised and engaged by her approach. A great start to a fantasy series and a world I loved spending time with – though readers beware that there are some mixed feelings on the third and fourth series entries.
(I enjoyed A Winter’s Promise so much that I introduced it to my partner, who has now made his way through the entire quarter. That also makes A Winter’s Promise my buddy read for this year’s 52 Book Club challenge! )
The Tainted Cup
It wouldn’t be a “best of fantasy” list for me without at least one Robert Jackson Bennett. And luckily for me, one of my favorite modern fantasy authors published a fantasy MYSTERY this year. The Tainted Cup follows investigator Ana Dolabra and her new assistant as they investigate the death of a high imperial officer. Their investigation takes them to the uppermost echelons of the government and the highest reaches of power. All this as the city faces intensifying magical and environmental threats…
The Tainted Cup feels like classic Bennett, with a more overt mystery twist. His two prior trilogies already feature a mystery-like structure, with protagonists uncovering and then remedying world-shattering secrets. The Tainted Cup leans into that structure, with Bennett building a complex world which he allows Dolabra and her assistant to peel off piece by piece. Fantasy mysteries can be difficult to write, because without the right worldbuilding, solutions can feel more deus ex machina than earned. Luckily, worldbuilding is one of Bennett’s strong suits, and The Tainted Cup is complex, imaginative, and thoroughly engaging.
The Book of Doors
It would also be quite difficult for me to write a “best of fantasy” list without a good bookish story in it. The Book of Doors was that story this year, a metaphorical exploration of all that books can bring us. The story follows Izzy, a bookseller handed a mysterious book by a favorite customer. She soon figures out that the book allows her to open doors to anywhere. Not only that – the book is one of many such powerful books, coveted by those in the know. She and her best friend, Izzy, soon find themselves caught up in a magical and dangerous quest to protect the books and their owners.
Reading The Book of Doors feels like riding a magical wave, rather than exploring a well-built world. This is very much soft fantasy – there are some rules to the books, but look to hard and they start to fall apart. Instead, the appeal of this story is how it captures the spirit of reading, both the good and the ugly. The books represent emotions and experiences, but also create communities and rivalries and danger. The right book at the right time can be an escape into a new life – but at the wrong time, it can lead you to despair and isolation. The Book of Doors is bookish fantasy that understands and explores books, and reminds us of how powerful reading can be.
Cassandra in Reverse
Last but not least is a little bit of an oddball book… (I may be telling myself that time travel is fantasy enough for this one to count.) Cassandra in Reverse tells the story of Cassandra, who struggles with work, with friends, with love. Cassie likes routines and hates her job, and struggles to build connections with those around her. When she finds out that she can time-travel, she starts using her power to reverse time and erase her mistakes through trial and error. (As someone who frequently rambles IRL to overcorrect for any offense I may have given, the idea of redos is quite appealing.)
Your reading of Cassie will vary – she reminds me most of Bernadette Fox, without the star accomplishments and “quirkiness” to make her endearing. I found her an accurate portrayal of how overwhelming it can be to navigate the world when it feels like your brain runs on a different OS. Others may find her abrasiveness and honest internal monologue too much to empathize with. Either way, Cassandra in Reverse takes Cassie through a satisfying growth arc that allows her to tackle each day more head-on. The ending may surprise those who spend time in different corners of the Internet than I do – but honestly, knowing the likely outcome made me like Cassie more, not less. Possibly the “spikiest” book on this list – but one that I appreciated for sharing the internal monologue of a striking, memorable character.
I actually have quite the backlog of fantasy reads for 2025, and would love to expand it – especially with great cozy fantasy. Any recommendations?
Last but not least are my favorite epistolaries for the year. Until tomorrow – stay cozy, and stay curious!
Leave a Reply